ComparisonsOct 3, 2026
If you like
Carolina Herrera · 2016
The stiletto-bottle scent that turned tuberose and cocoa into an office staple
It opens on almond and jasmine before tuberose and tonka bean move in, landing on a warm cocoa and amber base that reads sweet without being purely gourmand. The tension between a bright white floral top and a dark, dessert-like bottom is what people specifically hunt for when they say they miss it.
5 independent alternatives below
Try instead
Ranked by how much they share with Good Girl. The notes in common are listed under each bottle. Prices and stock come from the makers’ own shops.
Shares tonka bean and cocoa under a tuberose note. It is much sweeter and more playful: honeycomb, lemon sugar and cake, with no amber and no jasmine.
Shared notes
Covers the dark half only: cocoa, tonka bean and amber. There is no white floral here; pink pepper, cardamom and juniper give a spicier, drier opening.
Shared notes
Shares the jasmine, tuberose and tonka bean core. It is a perfume oil that sits closer to the skin, and peach, incense and ylang-ylang replace cocoa.
Shared notes
Shares tuberose, almond, tonka bean and amber. It is an attar built on honeyed orange blossom, aldehydes and ambergris, so brighter and waxier, with no cocoa or coffee.
Shared notes
Keep looking
The same territory, opened up in the library’s own filters.
These are independent suggestions based on shared notes and accords, not copies or dupes. Undernotes is not affiliated with Carolina Herrera; the name is used only to describe a smell. No link here is paid.
